PunditNG PunditNG app

Why a 70% hit rate can mean nothing

By · · 12,397 matches, 2023/24 to 2025/26

90%

of league matches had at least one goal. Pick "over 0.5" every time and you are right 9 times in 10, knowing nothing.

These are past results, not a tip. No bet here is safe. If betting stops being fun, Gamble Alert can help.

The trick: count the easy bets

Tipsters and prediction sites like to lead with one number: "70% of our picks win". It sounds like skill. But some bets come in most of the time whoever picks them. A record full of "over 0.5 goals", "under 4.5" and "home or draw" will show 70% or more without a single clever pick.

To see how much a hit rate is worth, I counted how often each common bet came in on its own: every finished league match in Europe's 5 big leagues and 8 African leagues, the NPFL among them, 2023/24 to 2025/26.

How often each bet came in on its own 11,894 league matches, 13 leagues, 2023/24 to 2025/26
  1. Under 5.5 goals 96%
  2. At least 1 goal 90%
  3. Under 4.5 goals 89%
  4. Under 3.5 goals 77%
  5. Home or draw 73%
  6. Home or away win 72%
  7. Over 1.5 goals 68%
  8. Under 2.5 goals 57%
  9. Not both score 53%
  10. Both teams score 47%
  11. Home win 46%
  12. Over 2.5 goals 43%
  13. Draw 28%
  14. Away win 27%

Shaded: bets that came in 70% of the time or more. Goals and results are at full time, after 90 minutes.

The leagues differ a lot. African leagues score fewer goals than Europe's: over 2.5 came in 35% of African matches against 54% in Europe's 5 big leagues. In the NPFL the home side won 66% of the time, so "home win" alone is right about 7 times in 10 there.

Bet Big 5EuropeAfrica8 leaguesNPFLNigeriaEPLEnglandUCLEurope
At least 1 goal 94%87%90%95%95%
Under 5.5 goals 93%98%98%93%88%
Under 4.5 goals 84%94%93%83%75%
Over 1.5 goals 78%60%61%82%81%
Home or draw 69%77%90%68%67%
Home or away win 74%71%76%76%83%
Under 3.5 goals 68%84%86%65%58%
Not both score 45%59%60%42%44%
Under 2.5 goals 46%65%65%41%37%
Over 2.5 goals 54%35%35%59%63%
Both teams score 55%41%40%58%56%
Home win 43%48%66%43%50%
Away win 31%23%10%32%33%
Draw 26%29%24%25%18%

Big 5: England, Spain, Italy, Germany and France. Africa: Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Kenya. UCL: the Champions League from the group or league stage on.

The favourite wins more often than you think

The bookmakers' favourite is the side with the shortest price. Over 2023/24 to 2025/26 it won 55% of 1,140 Premier League matches and 64% of 486 NPFL matches. A tipster who simply backs the favourite gets that hit rate. Yet the prices are set so that, over many bets, the favourite pays back less than it costs: the bookmaker's cut sits inside every price.

Four questions to ask about any hit rate

  1. Which bets? Ask for the hit rate on each type of bet, and set it against the table above. 75% on "over 1.5" in the Premier League is below the 82% it comes in anyway.
  2. At what prices? A hit rate makes money only if it times the average price is above 1. Right 60% of the time at an average of 1.50: ₦1,000 on each brings back ₦900 on average. Right 40% of the time at 3.00 brings back ₦1,200.
  3. Every pick, set before kick-off? A record that leaves out bad days, or adds picks after the match, can show anything. Ask for the full list with dates, losses included.
  4. How many picks? Over 25 picks, luck alone can move a hit rate about 20 points either way. Over 100, about 10. Over 400, about 5.

Our own calls are on the record page: every one, the losses included, what ₦10,000 on each would have returned, and how often each type of call comes in anyway.

The Premier League this season

After 100 matches of 2026/27, over 2.5 goals came in 47% of Premier League games: the lowest of the last six seasons at the same point. Both teams scored in 49%, against 58% over the three seasons before. The last 40 matches were quieter still: 2.40 goals a game, both teams scoring in 40%.

Season Goals a game Over 2.5 Both score 0-0
2021/22first 100 matches 2.82 54% 49% 6%
2022/23first 100 matches 2.87 54% 54% 10%
2023/24first 100 matches 3.03 64% 59% 3%
2024/25first 100 matches 2.88 56% 65% 4%
2025/26first 100 matches 2.68 54% 51% 6%
2026/27first 100 matches 2.73 47% 49% 6%

100 matches is a small sample: luck alone moves over 2.5 by about 10 points either way. A quiet start says little about the rest of the season.

League by league

League 1+ goal Over 2.5 Both score Home win Draw
Champions League503 matches 95% 63% 56% 50% 18%
GermanyBundesliga, 924 matches 95% 62% 60% 42% 26%
EnglandPremier League, 1,140 matches 95% 59% 58% 43% 25%
FranceLigue 1, 923 matches 93% 54% 54% 44% 24%
SpainLa Liga, 1,140 matches 94% 48% 53% 46% 26%
ItalySerie A, 1,140 matches 92% 48% 50% 40% 28%
MoroccoBotola Pro, 728 matches 89% 40% 48% 41% 31%
AlgeriaLigue 1, 720 matches 88% 39% 44% 50% 29%
EgyptPremier League, 852 matches 86% 38% 46% 35% 34%
NigeriaNPFL, 1,139 matches 90% 35% 40% 66% 24%
GhanaPremier League, 899 matches 87% 33% 35% 58% 26%
KenyaPremier League, 922 matches 86% 32% 41% 36% 33%
TunisiaLigue 1, 648 matches 84% 32% 33% 46% 29%
South AfricaPremier Soccer League, 719 matches 87% 31% 39% 42% 30%

How this was counted

Use these figures

The numbers and charts on this page are free to use in an article or a post. Please credit PunditNG and link to this page.

Source: PunditNG, punditng.com/research/base-rates/

Quick answers

What is a good hit rate for a tipster?

It depends on the bets. Set each type against how often it comes in anyway: in Europe's 5 big leagues at least one goal came in 94% of matches, over 2.5 goals 54%, a home win 43%. A hit rate is good only if it beats that, and it makes money only if the hit rate times the average price is above 1.

How often does over 0.5 goals come in?

In 94% of matches in Europe's 5 big leagues and 87% in 8 African leagues, 2023/24 to 2025/26. In the NPFL, 90%: about 1 match in 10 ends 0-0.

How often does the favourite win?

The bookmakers' favourite won 55% of Premier League matches and 64% of NPFL matches, 2023/24 to 2025/26. Backing the favourite every time gives that hit rate with no skill at all, and still loses money to the bookmaker's cut.